|
The trouble with the BOM
Despite 4,000 changes, Mormons maintain it is still the most correct book ever written - including the bible
This article will cover many of the changes to the Book of Mormon illustrating the ever-evolving theology of the Mormon Church. We present the following evidence:
We felt that it was important to start with what Mormons say about a particular change rather than have us do that. 
Therefore, don't take our word for it, listen to how Mormon scholars explain away changes to the BoM while maintaining that it is the most correct book ever written:
1. "Born of a Virgin" Change - as told by FAIR
"In 1837 Joseph Smith made several editorial changes in the Book of Mormon. Many are relatively innocuous, but one of them is much more substantial. In the 1830 edition of the Book of Mormon, the verse we know as 1 Nephi 11:18 reads:
And he said unto me: Behold, the virgin whom thou seest is the mother of God, after the manner of the flesh.
For the 1837 edition, Joseph inserted "the Son of," so that the verse has read ever since:
And he said unto me: Behold, the virgin whom thou seest is the mother of the Son of God, after the manner of the flesh.
There is no way to know just what was on Joseph Smith's mind when he made that change, but that hasn't stopped a lot of people from trying.
However, when we focus on the fact of the change, we inherently begin to ask the wrong questions. Several authors have discussed this change as evidence of an evolving LDS theology of God. That very question implicitly supposes Joseph Smith as the author of the Book of Mormon by assuming that the Book of Mormon is evidence of Joseph's early thought. If we believe the Book of Mormon, it isn't. The Book of Mormon doesn't represent Joseph's theology--it represents Nephite theology."
To read the complete text please go to FAIR LDS.
-----------------------------
We at Life After Ministries wish to thank Mormons like Brant Gardner who wrote the preceding "defense" of his faith. We also wish to thank "FAIR" for publishing it on their site. We are happy to see Mormon Scholars so willing to give Joseph Smith, the proprieter of Mormonsim, the benefit of the doubt. Therefore, we call on FAIR to act in a manner consistent with its name, and instruct all Mormons, via its website, to be as pragmatic about judging the intentions of early Christian theologians as they are about the judging the intentions of their own.
Moreover, we are shocked that scholars from an organzation calling itself by the name of FAIR would start with a conclusion that the Book of Mormon is necessarily true and then reverse engineer the data to meet that conclusion (please note the underlined text above). Instead, we call on all Mormons to start with a hypothesis of "The Book is Mormon is Another Testament of Jesus Christ" and reasearch forward, letting the data prove or disprove the hypothesis of their theories.
In The Final Analysis
It would seem that sometimes the Church of Latter-day Saints is its own worst enemy. By making such unsubstantiated claims that "the Book of Mormon is the most correct book ever," they leave themselves completely open to criticism. It's almost as if the Mormon Church invites the criticism, likes the criticism, is more comfortable playing the victim rather than facing the obvious and confounding issues that dog the Country's 4th largest dominiation. Instead, time after time, it has been our experience, whether we're dealing with members, missionaries or leaders of the Mormon Church, that despite the "prophectic" claims from their founder that they would confound their enemies, the Mormon church as a whole, runs away from defending their faith despite the claim that they are "true church." We should think that members of the 'true church' could do as much. But such is not the case leaving themselves open to criticism.
The Book of Mormon is just another one of many examples. It has many problems. Any person willing to take a close enough, critical look at the BOM, or the Church and its doctrines for that matter, can find the serious doctrinal problems with Mormonism. However, the Mormon Church preys on ignorance. It prefers that its members only look as deep as they are told to. It's part of the indoctrination process to keep its members where they are--safely within the church's control. If the Church member begins to look deeper and form their own conclusions, and in essence face the facts themselves, the entire illusion quickly unravels because any decerning follower of Mormonism quickly finds themselves in a deeper sea of questions rather than in a deeper sea of faith.
Therefore, in its haste to make sure all the doctrine lines up in the Church of Latter-day Saints, the Church has changed, tweaked and excused (as you have seen above) its countless alterations to the Book of Mormon as mostly grammatical fixes while at the same time it blasts Christians on charges that the Bible is flawed because of its many translations. It matters not in the least to the LDS Church that their hypocrisy is fully exposed when they deny, if you follow their line of reasoning, that the Book of Mormon, after being translated in Spanish is somehow less reliable than its English counterpart. What's more, major portions of the Book of Mormon are copied directly from the Bible, particularly from the book of Isaiah. It begs the question in that sense, "How can something so vile and polluted like the Bible as Mormons claim it is, be poured into something so correct, like the Book of Mormon, and not remain unpolluted itself?" Does it not stand to reason that if we have a a glass of dirty water and pour it into a glass of pure water, does not the pure water become polluted?
Furthermore, if the Book of Mormon is the most correct book ever written, why would the LDS Church tell its missionaries to leave behind the Bible? Is this not the least bit curious to the average Mormon that they would not leave behind something other than "the most correct book ever written?"
In what is a classic example of finger pointing, Mormons continue on this crusade about the Book of Mormon and its perfection. Any discussion about the book will eventually lead to its "sacredness" despite what we have discussed here.
So we thought it would be helpful to point out some of the changes to the BOM and also show where the Bible, in the Mormon's eyes, gets a bum rap.
More will follow on this subject soon and we'll examine the specific charges on both sides in the weeks to come.
For more information on Mormon beliefs, please go to www.lifeafter.org. Life After Ministries is a donor supported ministry that cannot spead the Gospel to deceived Mormons without your help.
Please give.
|
